Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Library DIY

Navigating UWG library resources and research

What does peer-review mean?

Academic peer-review is a process through which scholarly work is reviewed by experts in a field before a decision is made to publish the work.

Names for peer-reviewed articles

  • Peer-reviewed
  • Scholarly
  • Academic
  • Refereed

Peer review process

Note: The process described below reflects the review process for peer-reviewed articles published in academic journals. Some academic books (e.g., many published by university presses) are also peer reviewed and follow a similar process.

  • Draft of article is sent to the journal editors, who send the article to experts in the field (reviewers). 
  • Reviewers evaluate the accuracy, quality, and originality of the research documented in the article.
  • Reviewers make one of the following recommendations: published in its current form; publish after required revisions; revise and resubmit; reject. 
  • Editor sends the author the final editorial decision.
  • If appropriate, author revises the article based on feedback. Editor or reviewers review the article again.
  • If appropriate, the article is published.

Common characteristics of peer-reviewed articles

  •  The author's credentials include an advanced degree and an affiliation with a university or research institution.
  •  The writing style uses technical terms because it is written for other scholars.
  •  The article contains an abstract, literature review, and reference list.

Video "Peer Review in Three Minutes